There’s nothing better than being able to grab your car keys and drive yourself wherever it is that you need to go. Whether it’s commuting to work, running errands, exciting adventures, or even Sunday drives with no destination, car ownership offers freedom, flexibility, and convenience. Despite all of the benefits that car ownership provides, it is a responsibility and it’s one that should be taken seriously. Unless you have experience working on cars yourself, you should leave your car servicing and repairs to a professional. You have two options when it comes to car repairs: take it to a dealer or a local mechanic. Which one should you choose? Let’s explore.

Should I Go to a Dealer or a Mechanic for a Car Repair?

After all, a car is an investment, and like any other investment, if you want it to last as long as possible, it needs to be properly taken care of. With that said, one of the most important things you can do for your vehicle is to have it repaired or serviced whenever necessary.

Whether it’s car maintenance like an oil change, a tune-up, new tires, or auto repairs when it is making strange clunking sounds and you need to have it looked at, always treat your car with care. But where should you take your car?

Local Mechanic vs. Car Dealership


One of the biggest reasons to take your car to a mechanic instead of a dealership is cost. Dealerships often charge more for repairs and maintenance than independent mechanics. This is because dealerships have higher overhead costs, such as marketing expenses and rent for a large showroom. Additionally, dealerships often use original equipment manufacturer (OEM) parts, which can be more expensive than the same aftermarket parts used by mechanics.

Personalized Service

Another reason to consider taking your car to a mechanic is the personalized service you can receive. When you take your car to a dealer service department, you’re likely to interact with a different person every time you visit. This makes it difficult to develop a relationship with your service advisor. In contrast, a mechanic at an independent shop can provide more personalized service and get to know you and your car’s unique needs.


Mechanics can often be more flexible with scheduling and providing quick service. Many independent mechanics have smaller operations and can be more nimble in terms of scheduling and prioritizing repairs. Additionally, since mechanics are independent operators, they have a personal stake in your level of customer service. This can motivate the mechanic to go above and beyond to provide fast, quality service.


Mechanics typically specialize in a certain area, such as brakes or transmissions, and have honed their skills through years of experience repairing and servicing cars. This expertise means that they can diagnose problems more accurately and quickly than a dealership service department, which has to be familiar with a wide range of vehicles and issues. Additionally, mechanics can provide recommendations on how to best maintain your car for optimal performance.


Finally, taking your car to an honest mechanic can build trust. A good mechanic will provide transparent pricing and explain repairs in detail so that you can understand the work being done. This transparency can help build trust, and give you peace of mind knowing that you’re not being taken advantage of.

Disadvantages of Car Dealerships for Auto Repairs

Wait times

Because dealerships often service a large number of cars each day, wait times for service can be longer than at an independent mechanic. This can be particularly frustrating if you need your car back quickly and don’t want to sit in a waiting room all afternoon.


Dealerships may have more rigid policies and schedules when it comes to service appointments, and may not be as willing to work with you to accommodate your needs. In contrast, independent mechanics may be more flexible and willing to work around your schedule.

Contact a Local Auto Mechanic

While both mechanics and dealerships can provide quality repairs, there are many reasons to consider taking your car to your Omaha neighborhood mechanic. From cost savings to personalized service, mechanics can offer many benefits that make them a great choice for car repairs. So, the next time your car needs work, consider giving your local mechanic a call instead of a dealer. Schedule an appointment for your vehicle at our shop here.

Dave & Rays Automotive Repair Shop in Omaha, NE

Our team has learned one thing: automotive problems are as varied and unique as the customers who bring them to us. Fortunately, our decades of experience in auto service and repair also mean that our skilled network of professionals is ready to accommodate an impressive scope of automotive issues. Contact us today.

Recent Articles